Enhancing Boiler Efficiency with Turbulator Inserts: An In-Depth Look
When it comes to industrial boilers, improving efficiency is a top priority. Fire tube boilers, commonly used for generating steam in various applications, have seen numerous innovations aimed at reducing fuel consumption and increasing overall efficiency. One such innovation is the use of turbulator inserts. In this post, we'll explore what turbulators are, how they work, and the benefits and trade-offs associated with their use, drawing on findings from a detailed study conducted by the Heat Transfer Laboratory at Iowa State University.
What are Turbulator Inserts?
Turbulators are devices inserted into the tubes of a boiler to enhance heat transfer. They are typically made of narrow, thin metal strips that are bent and twisted in a zig-zag fashion. The purpose of these inserts is to disrupt the flow of hot gases within the boiler tubes, creating turbulence. This turbulence increases the heat transfer coefficient, which means more heat from the hot gases is transferred to the water inside the tubes, ultimately producing more steam.
Comparing Three Types of Turbulator Inserts
The study at Iowa State University evaluated three different types of commercial turbulator inserts to determine their effectiveness in enhancing heat transfer. Here's a comparison of the key findings:
Angular Turbulators (Type A and Type B):
Heat Transfer Performance: Angular Turbulator inserts significantly increased the heat transfer coefficient, with Type A showing a 157% improvement and Type B showing a 125% improvement at a Reynolds number of 10,700. These turbulators were particularly effective due to their design, which promoted more efficient mixing of the hot gases.
Friction Factor: The increased friction was substantial, with Type A and Type B inserts causing a rise in friction factors by approximately 1110% and 1000%, respectively. This increase in friction means more energy is required to push the gases through the tubes.
Twisted Tape Turbulators (Type C Turbulator):
Heat Transfer Performance: The twisted tape turbulator insert, while still effective, only improved the heat transfer coefficient by 60%. This makes it less efficient compared to angular, but it comes with a trade-off.
Friction Factor: The friction factor increase for twisted tape turbulators was much lower, at around 120%, making it a potentially better option where minimizing pressure drop and energy costs is a priority.
Practical Implications: Choosing the Right Turbulator
The comparison of these three types of turbulators highlights an important consideration for anyone looking to improve boiler efficiency: the trade-off between enhanced heat transfer and increased flow resistance.
Angular Turbulator Inserts: These are the best options if maximizing heat transfer is your primary goal. However, the significant increase in friction means you'll need to be prepared for higher air flow requirements.
Twisted Tape Turbulator Inserts: This turbulator offers a more balanced approach, providing a decent increase in heat transfer with a much smaller impact on the friction factor. It might be the preferred choice in scenarios where increasing airflow is not an option.
Conclusion: Are Turbulators Worth It?
The decision to use turbulator inserts in a fire tube boiler should be based on a careful consideration of the specific circumstances of your operation. If your goal is to maximize heat transfer and you're prepared to manage the associated increases in flow resistance angular turbulators can be highly effective. However, if you’re looking for a middle ground, twisted tape turbulators may offer a more balanced solution.
By understanding both the benefits and the potential drawbacks, you can make an informed decision about whether turbulator inserts are the right choice for your boiler system. With the right approach, these inserts could play a key role in improving the energy efficiency of your operations.
Follow the link below to see our offering for both types of turbulators
*Junkhan, G. H., Bergles, A. E., Nirmalan, V., & Ravigururajan, T. (1983). Investigation of Turbulators for Fire Tube Boilers (ASME Report No. 83-HT-44). The American Society of Mechanical Engineers.