Enhancing Heat Transfer in Heat Exchangers with Twisted Tape Inserts

Heat exchangers are vital components in various industries, from power plants to refrigeration systems, where efficient heat transfer is crucial. Over the years, engineers and researchers have developed numerous techniques to enhance the performance of heat exchangers. One of the most effective methods is the use of twisted tape inserts, a passive technique that has garnered significant attention due to its simplicity and effectiveness.

 

Understanding Heat Transfer Enhancement Techniques

Before diving into twisted tape inserts, it’s essential to understand the broader context of heat transfer enhancement techniques. These techniques can be categorized into three main types:

  • Active Techniques: These involve external power input to enhance heat transfer. Examples include mechanical aids like surface vibration and the use of magnetic fields to disturb the flow of fluid.

  • Passive Techniques: Unlike active methods, passive techniques do not require any external power. Instead, they use modifications within the system, such as adding twisted tapes or wire coils, to disrupt fluid flow and increase heat transfer. This method typically results in an increased fluid pressure drop but significantly improves heat transfer efficiency.

  • Compound Techniques: These combine active and passive methods to achieve even greater enhancement. By leveraging the strengths of multiple techniques, compound methods can offer superior performance, albeit with increased complexity and cost.

 

What Are Twisted Tape Inserts?

Twisted tape inserts are metallic strips twisted and inserted into the flow of a fluid within a heat exchanger. These tapes induce a swirling motion in the fluid, which disturbs the boundary layers and enhances heat transfer. The design of the twisted tape—specifically the pitch (the distance between two points on the same plane) plays a crucial role in its effectiveness.

 

Benefits and Trade-offs

The primary advantage of using twisted tape inserts is the significant enhancement in heat transfer. By increasing the turbulence in the fluid, these inserts allow more efficient heat exchange between the fluid and the surfaces of the heat exchanger. However, this comes at the cost of an increased pressure drop, which can require more powerful pumps to maintain the same flow rate.

 

Real-World Applications and Research Findings

Research has shown that twisted tape inserts are particularly effective in various configurations:

 

  • Full-Length Twisted Tapes: These are inserted along the entire length of the heat exchanger tube and are most effective in enhancing heat transfer, albeit with a corresponding increase in pressure drop.

  • Short-Length Twisted Tapes: These are used in specific sections of the tube to balance heat transfer enhancement with pressure drop concerns.

  • Variations in Pitch and Twist Ratio: Studies have indicated that tapes with a lower twist ratio (meaning tighter twists) generally offer better heat transfer performance, though they also result in higher pressure drops.

For instance, in an experiment involving the condensation of refrigerant HFC-134a, it was observed that a twisted tape with a twist ratio of 6 provided the highest enhancement in heat transfer and pressure drop. On the other hand, a twist ratio of 9 offered the best balance, minimizing pressure drop while still enhancing heat transfer.

 

Economic and Practical Considerations

Twisted tape inserts are not only effective but also economical and easy to install, making them an attractive option for retrofitting existing heat exchangers. Their simplicity means that they can be easily manufactured and deployed in various industrial applications. However, it is important to consider the fluid’s properties, when choosing twisted tape inserts.

 

Conclusion: A Simple Yet Powerful Tool for Heat Transfer Enhancement

Twisted tape inserts represent a powerful, passive technique for enhancing heat transfer in heat exchangers. While they do introduce a trade-off in terms of increased pressure drop, their benefits in terms of improved heat exchanger efficiency often outweigh the downsides. As research continues to refine these designs, particularly in exploring different geometries and twist ratios, twisted tapes will likely remain a cornerstone of heat exchanger technology, helping industries achieve more efficient thermal management.

Follow the link below to see our offering of twisted tape turbulators

*Ubale, D. P. (2017, June). Heat transfer enhancement in heat exchanger using twisted tape inserts: A review. Paper presented at the International Conference on Ideas, Impact and Innovation in Mechanical Engineering (ICIIIME 2017), Mumbai, India. International Journal on Recent and Innovation Trends in Computing and Communication, 5(6), 425-428.